The completion funnel: where players quit
The biggest drop in Harold Halibut is inside chapter 1 itself: 85.2% of players take the tube, only 42.4% finish the chapter. The next 10.5 points go between chapter 1 and chapter 2.
Steam records 27 achievements for Harold Halibut, and the order they unlock in is the most precise picture of the game's audience anyone has. 85.2% of owners take a tube ride. 42.4% finish the first chapter. 18.1% see the ending.
A 67-point fall from the opening minutes to the credits, and it does not happen evenly. Two drops account for most of it, and one of them is inside chapter 1, before the story has done anything at all.
| Stage | Achievement | Global % | Drop |
|---|---|---|---|
| First tube ride | Tubular! | 85.2 | — |
| Chapter 1 side content | Après Ski | 57.4 | 27.8 |
| Chapter 1 finished | A Slice of Life | 42.4 | 15.0 |
| Chapter 2 finished | The Adventure Begins | 31.9 | 10.5 |
| Chapter 3 finished | A New Shape of Soul | 28.6 | 3.3 |
| Chapter 4 finished | Cultural Liaison | 22.6 | 6.0 |
| Chapter 5 finished | Chasing Dragons | 22.4 | 0.2 |
| Chapter 6 finished | Justice Is a Dish Best Served Warm | 22.1 | 0.3 |
| Game finished | Home Is Where the Heart Is | 18.1 | 4.0 |
All figures are Steam's global achievement percentages, read on 17 November 2026.

Inside chapter 1, a cliff
Most games lose players between chapters. This one loses them inside the first two hours.
Tubular! sits at 85.2%, and it unlocks on the first tube ride, which happens in chapter 1.1, roughly ten minutes in. A Slice of Life sits at 42.4%, at the end of chapter 1. Between those two points, 42.8 points of players stopped.
The middle row explains where. Après Ski, which is trying out Slippie's ski slope in the Agora Arcades, sits at 57.4%. A two-minute optional interaction in a district the main story walks you through. Fifteen points of players finished the ski slope and then never finished the chapter.
What happens between 1.2 and 1.6 is not difficult. It is slow: a rock sample to inspect, a walk across four districts to deliver it, a vent crawl, and a filtration pump at the end of a long corridor. The game's walking speed is deliberate, and it is the first thing every review mentions.
Chapter 2 and its curfew
The drop from chapter 1 to chapter 2 is 10.5 points, the largest between-chapter fall in the game. Chapter 2 also contains the only day-ending trap in the game: talking to Sunny in 2.1 fires a curfew and closes the chapter's optional content.
Two numbers in the same chapter tell that story. 31.9% finish chapter 2. 29.6% have Rubadubdub, the achievement for hearing the announcer under the shower in the Social District. So most people who finish the chapter did the shower room, which is at least one optional room. But Entertainment Onat Fan Club sits at 16.1%, and that is the stage show in the arcade, one district away.
Chapter 2 is where the game's optional layer stops being free. It is also where the audience stops being a crowd.
A long, flat middle
From chapter 3 to chapter 6, the line is almost flat: 28.6, 22.6, 22.4, 22.1. Nineteen points of the audience leave in chapters 3 and 4, and then almost nobody leaves in chapters 5 and 6.
Most games behave the other way round, and there is a mechanical reason. Chapters 3, 5 and 6 are linear, short and impossible to fail, and chapter 5 and 6 have nothing missable in them at all. Players who reach chapter 5 arrive at the part where the story is going somewhere, and they finish.
The 6-point drop between chapter 3 and chapter 4 is the interesting one. Chapter 4 is the only open chapter, the only one with an order you can get wrong, and the only one where a quest can destroy an achievement. Some of those 6 points did not quit; they got lost in a day with eleven conversations, six letters and a heist in it.
Epilogue drop
22.1% finish chapter 6. 18.1% finish the game. Four points of players watch the showdown, then stop before the farewell tour.
The epilogue is a series of goodbyes: the brothers, Onat, Warren, Major, Zoya, CEO Casselchop, then Weeoo. Six of those conversations hold the last notebook entries, which is why Forschergeist (1.9%) is so much rarer than finishing the game.
The epilogue is also where the achievement list and the story diverge completely. A player who says goodbye to Weeoo immediately finishes the game and locks themselves out of five notebook entries. Talking to everyone first is not optional if you are collecting, and the game does not say so.
Where the numbers stop
These are shares of everyone who owns the game, which includes people who bought it in a sale and never launched it. The true completion rate among people who actually started is higher than 42.4% at chapter 1, though nobody publishes that number, and Steam's own refund window means the 85.2% figure includes players who played for twenty minutes.
The shape is still right. A game that loses half its audience before the end of the first chapter has a pacing problem, not a difficulty problem, and Harold Halibut's reviews say the same thing in words: the craft is extraordinary, the pace is not. The review breakdown puts those two claims side by side.
Using the funnel
About to start? The funnel is a warning about the first two hours. They are the slowest part of the game, and the story has not started yet. Push past the filtration pump.
Stuck deciding whether to keep going? The flattened line from chapter 3 onwards is the argument for continuing: people who get that far finish.
Achievement hunters get the reason the completion run is a planning problem. Everything rare sits in the day-locked chapters, and the 100% route exists because of that.