1,238 reviews at 81%, 17 recent ones at 64%
The all-time Steam score is 81% positive from 1,238 reviews; the last 30 days are 64% from 17. Critics average 69 on Metacritic and 71 on OpenCritic. Both groups say the same thing: the craft is exceptional, the pace is not.
Steam showed 1,238 Harold Halibut reviews at 81% positive on 17 November 2026, and 17 reviews from the previous thirty days at 64%. One store page, one build, two verdict bands. The distance between them is about three people.
Three reviews moved the last-30-day number
At 17 reviews a single one is worth 5.9 percentage points, so the recent line moves in visible jumps. Holding 81% across seventeen reviews needs fourteen positive and three negative. The window actually contains eleven positive and six, which is 64.7% and rounds down to the 64% Steam displayed on 17 November 2026.
Three people who did not enjoy themselves account for the whole drop. Neither a review bomb nor a collapse.
The lifetime number is slower than it looks, too. 1,238 reviews since the 16 April 2024 release works out at roughly forty a month; seventeen in the last thirty days is below that pace, so the recent window is a trickle rather than a surge of complaint.

Seven numbers, side by side
| Signal | Value | Source | What it means |
|---|---|---|---|
| Steam, all time | 1,238 reviews, 81% positive | Steam store page, read 17 Nov 2026 | The settled score, and the one search results quote |
| Steam, last 30 days | 17 reviews, 64% positive | Steam store page, read 17 Nov 2026 | Eleven positive reviews against six negative ones |
| Metacritic | 69, from 28 critics | Metacritic, read 17 Nov 2026 | Twelve points below the Steam all-time figure |
| OpenCritic | 71 average, 58% of 59 critics recommend | OpenCritic, read 17 Nov 2026 | About 34 of those 59 would tell a friend to buy it |
| Finished chapter 1 | 42.4% of players | Steam global achievements, read 17 Nov 2026 | More than half never reach the second chapter |
| Finished the game | 18.1% of players | Steam global achievements, read 17 Nov 2026 | Fewer than one in five can describe the ending |
| PlayStation Store rating | 4.07 out of 5, about 2.9K ratings | PS Store, read 17 Nov 2026 | Console buyers land where Steam's all-time score does |
The two Steam figures also sit in different bands. 81% is inside Steam's Very Positive range, 64% is inside Mixed, so a store widget can look like a different product from one month to the next without a single review being deleted.
Critics and buyers disagree by twelve points
Metacritic's 69 from 28 critics is twelve points under the Steam all-time percentage, and OpenCritic's 71 average from 59 critics comes with 58% recommending, roughly thirty-four of them. Wikipedia's reception summary, checked on the same day, calls the reviews mixed: praise for the ambition and detail of the visual presentation and for the themes, criticism for the lack of puzzles and interactivity and for the slow pace.
Read together, the two camps are not arguing about craft. They are arguing about what the game is for: a hand-built diorama you walk through, or a puzzle box you solve.
Three complaints, and the number behind each
- Slow pace. HowLongToBeat's 221 polled players put the main story at 10½ hours, 13½ with side content and 17½ for a completionist run, with 5.8% marked retired. Steam's chapter 1 achievement has been earned by 42.4% of players, so most of the audience is judging a ten-hour game on its opening two hours.
- No puzzles to speak of. The game ships 27 achievements and 71 notebook entries, and the questions that send people looking for a guide are a short list: a door password, a missing adapter, a medicine that does not matter, a bird that will not sit still, six letters. The data suggests the audience arrived expecting a point-and-click and found a walking tour.
- Little interactivity. No difficulty settings, one save slot, one ending, and a final decision that is scripted rather than chosen. The Exchanger Arranger achievement, which asks for eleven conversations inside chapter 4.2, has been earned by 3.6% of players.
None of those complaints is about the visual presentation or the themes, which is the odd part of the split. 81% and 64% describe the same game; the gap reads as different amounts of patience.
How to tell whether the negative reviews apply to you
Work down the list. The first line that describes you is the answer.
- You want a puzzle every twenty minutes. Skip it. The documented puzzle set is small, and chapter 5 is linear with nothing missable in it.
- You play in short sessions. Chapter 1 alone runs to six sub-chapters, and the first is an office, a fine and a conversation. 42.4% of players stop somewhere inside that.
- You need the ending to justify the trip. 18.1% finish. The epilogue is a farewell tour of the cast, not a twist that rewrites what came before.
- You are paying $34.99 for agency. Ten and a half hours of story with one save slot, one ending and no difficulty settings is the whole purchase.
If none of those four describes you, the 81% is closer to your evening than the 64% is.
Reading the split honestly
Harold Halibut was a day-one Game Pass title in April 2024 and left the service on 15 April 2025. Steam reviews come from people who own the game there, so the 1,238 reads as the verdict of players who paid $34.99 for something that looks like nothing else on the store, not the verdict of everyone who ever tried it.
PlayStation buyers are the larger sample and the quieter one. 4.07 out of 5 from about 2.9K ratings, read on 17 November 2026, is close to the Steam all-time score and a long way from the recent 64%. The Switch 2 version arrived on 12 November 2026, five days before these figures were read, so its buyers are in none of them yet.
Seventeen reviews cannot establish a trend. What they can do is repeat the three complaints critics made in April 2024, which reads as the old argument being restated by a handful of people who stopped early rather than a new problem appearing two and a half years after launch.
The full drop-off is in the completion funnel, the hour-by-hour comparison is in how long to beat, and the table behind the 42.4% and 18.1% figures is in all 27 achievements. Still deciding? The worth-it page weighs these numbers against the $34.99.