Harold Halibut Guide English

Chapter 2: The Creature from the Sea

Quick answer

The curfew fires the moment you talk to Sunny for the medicine, so finish every side errand in 2.1 before that conversation. Chapter 2 is also where 10.5% of players stop: 42.4% finished chapter 1, 31.9% finished chapter 2.

Chapter 2 is where the game stops being about errands and starts being about the ship. It is also the chapter with the single most punishing timing rule in Harold Halibut: one conversation ends the day, and it is a conversation you are looking forward to.

Six sub-chapters, from a creature in the filtration system to a submarine trip into the ocean outside the hull. Here is each one, with the missable content placed where it happens.

Official Harold Halibut screenshot from the Fedora

2.1 The Creature from the Sea

The chapter opens with a new arrival: a fish-like humanoid stuck in the ship's filtration system, which Harold ends up calling Fishy. The first task is physical, three trips carrying boxes to Harold's bedroom, which ends in an item-stacking minigame. Drop the items anywhere; the scene resolves either way.

Then the chapter opens up, and this is the day that punishes impatience.

The curfew rule. Talking to Sunny in the Utility District triggers the curfew, and the curfew ends the day. Everything optional in 2.1 has to happen before that conversation. Marching straight to the pharmacy because the objective says so loses you the arcade, the shower room and the post office in one go.

The full sweep, in a sensible order:

  1. Social District: head right for a scene, then into the hallway with the yellow signs. Second door, back of the room, interact with the bathroom to hear the announcer under the shower. That unlocks Rubadubdub (29.6%) and the Announcer entry (22 of 71).
  2. Agora Arcades: Warren and his water wieners (entry 23), the soup lady twice (Quick Soap Colorfish, entry 24), Zoya at the arcade machine, then Onat's stage show for Entertainment Onat Fan Club (16.1%).
  3. Energy District: Buddy at the post office. Look at the Certificate of Participation and start reading the old letters. This is the beginning of the longest achievement in the game.
  4. Lab District: back to the storage room for the Secret Guest entry (21).
  5. Utility District: only now, talk to Sunny.
StopDistrictActionWhat you get
Shower roomSocial DistrictInteract with the bathroomRubadubdub, The Announcer 22/71
WarrenAgora ArcadesTalk about the wienersWater Wieners 23/71
Soup ladyAgora ArcadesTalk twiceQuick Soap Colorfish 24/71
OnatAgora ArcadesWatch the stage showEntertainment Onat Fan Club
BuddyEnergy DistrictStart reading lettersThe Postman Always Rings Twice, part 1
SunnyUtility DistrictTalkCurfew, day ends

2.2 Taking Care

A quieter day: check on Fishy in the storage room, then go back to the arcade for Warren's culinary tips. He runs out of dialogue eventually, and leaving the district and returning refreshes the conversation.

Brigitte's first bacteria task is available in the Social District. Do it, and note that her second one will not open until Fishy has had the medicine.

The letter reading continues at the post office. Adilah's letter and the cease-and-desist from All Water Corp are the two for this chapter's middle days.

2.3 The Right Care

Fishy is worse. The day runs: check the creature, go to the Utility District, get medicine from Sunny, bring it back.

Two medicines are offered. Either works. There is no branch, no consequence and no achievement attached, and any guide telling you otherwise is inventing a choice the game does not make. What is worth planning is everything around the errand, because the medicine is the day's main task and it closes the day when you deliver it.

Once Fishy has been treated, Brigitte's second bacteria task opens. Dinner with Brigitte at the Agora Arcade is the evening scene.

Details, including why the medicine itself does not matter: which medicine.

2.4 All Water Conspiracy

The political chapter. Harold sits through the vote scenes, gets the Rogue Bacteria entry (32 of 71), and then picks up a message from the Lightkeepers, the group that has been nudging him since chapter 1.

This is also where Coco comes back. On your return to the Lab District after the Rafi conversation, the bird appears in the hallway, Harold chases her into Mareaux's lab, and the Catching Coco entry lands. No achievement, two entries, and one of them is the payoff for a promise Zoya made a chapter earlier.

Followers of the gossip thread should catch the couples in Gertrude's bar in this stretch, discussing the relaunch presentation. One third of Busybody (6.4%), the second-rarest achievement in the game.

More on the bird: where to find Coco.

2.5 The Creature Awakens

Social District, Chris's classroom, a room full of children with questions. Answer however you like; the game does not track it. Then back to the lab for the Fishy scene that closes the sub-chapter.

Nothing is missable here, and it is the last calm day before the submarine.

2.6 Leaving the Fedora

Tea with Mareaux and Weeoo, then down the lift, up the ladder on the right, and into the submarine. The Submarine entry is 34 of 71.

The trip is an auto-scroller: steer around the obstacles, keep moving right. The chapter ends on arrival, and The Adventure Begins unlocks (31.9%).

What chapter 2 costs

Chapter 2 is the second-biggest drop in the game: 42.4% finished chapter 1, 31.9% finished chapter 2. 10.5 points of players, and the numbers inside the chapter say where they went. The chapter 2 achievement sits at 31.9% while the chapter 1 achievement sits at 42.4%, but Rubadubdub (29.6%) and Entertainment Onat Fan Club (16.1%) show that a lot of the people who finished the chapter never did the optional rooms.

The curfew is the mechanical reason. A player who beelines for Sunny in 2.1 finishes the chapter and skips half of it, and nothing warns them.

Checklist, if you read nothing else

Before you talk to Sunny in 2.1: shower room, arcade, post office, storage room. Before you deliver the medicine in 2.3: Brigitte's second task. Before you leave for the submarine in 2.6: the Catching Coco scene in the lab.

The chapter 1 walkthrough covers what came before; the chapter 3 walkthrough picks up after the submarine. For everything missable across the run, keep the notebook page open.