Which medicine for Fishy
Pick either medicine. Both produce the same result and the story does not branch. What actually matters is doing every side errand in chapter 2.1 before you talk to Sunny, because that conversation triggers the curfew.
Either medicine works. The two options Sunny offers produce the same result, the story does not branch, and no achievement is tied to the choice. Standing in the pharmacy weighing them up? Pick whichever you like and move on.
What is worth knowing is why the choice exists at all, and what the real decision on that day actually is.

The medicine day, step by step
Chapter 2.3 opens with Fishy worse. Harold checks on the creature in the storage room, gets told the condition has not improved, and is sent back to Sunny in the Utility District for a specific medication.
Sunny presents two medicines. You choose one. You carry it back to the Lab District, give it to Fishy, and the day continues into dinner with Brigitte at the Agora Arcade.
The whole branch fits in one line: no later scene references which one you picked, no character reacts differently, and the ending is unaffected. Neoseeker's chapter 2.3 walkthrough states it plainly: select any medicine, as this will not affect the story's outcome.
| Choice | Story outcome | Achievement | Notes |
|---|---|---|---|
| First medicine | Fishy is treated, day continues | None | Safe |
| Second medicine | Fishy is treated, day continues | None | Safe |
| Refusing or leaving | Not a branch the game offers | None | The scene requires a pick |
If a page tells you one medicine is the correct one, that page is inventing a consequence the game does not have. Neither option is a good or bad outcome for Fishy, and choosing wrong cannot lose you the creature.
The decision that does matter
The real trap on this day is upstream of the pharmacy.
Chapter 2 runs on days, and a day ends when its main objective is finished. That means every optional conversation, every notebook entry and every side errand in the chapter has to happen before the main task closes the day. Chapter 2.1 is the sharpest example: talking to Sunny for the first time triggers the curfew, and the curfew ends the day.
So the useful advice is not "pick medicine A". It is:
- Before you talk to Sunny at any point in chapter 2, finish the conversations you came for.
- Check the PDA's optional list, not just the main objective. Optional tasks do not block the day, but they expire with it.
- Do the room you are in before the room you are going to. The Lab District's storage room, Chris's classroom and the arcade all sit on different tube lines.
- Save the main objective for last, every day, in chapters 1, 2 and 4.
That habit is worth more than any single answer in this chapter. It is also the reason 31.9% of Steam players finish chapter 2 while 42.4% finish chapter 1: the players who quit here did not fail a puzzle, they lost a day's optional content and stopped caring.
Why Fishy matters
Fishy is the fish-like humanoid Harold finds stuck in the ship's filtration system, and the medicine day is the point where the creature stops being a secret in a box and becomes a character with a stake in the plot. The treatment is the first time the ship's machinery and the planet's biology are shown to be compatible, which is the theme the last two chapters run on.
None of that depends on which bottle you pick. The scene is about Harold choosing to keep the creature alive, and the game treats the choice of medicine as flavour rather than characterisation.
Downstream effects
One thing does change, and it is not the medicine itself: Brigitte's second bacteria task opens only after Fishy has been treated. Putting off the medicine run to sweep side content leaves Brigitte's optional task locked until the creature has had its dose.
Order that avoids the dead end:
- Do the morning check on Fishy, which starts the day.
- Sweep the arcade and the Social District for conversations before you go to the pharmacy.
- Buy the medicine, any medicine.
- Deliver it, then go back to Brigitte for the second bacteria task.
- Finish the day with dinner.
Doing Brigitte's task before the medicine leaves her with nothing new to say, and the window to do it properly is the same day.
Common confusion
"Is there a correct medicine for the achievement?" No. The 27 achievements include nothing that reads on this choice, and the two rarest in this part of the game are about conversations and collection, not medicine.
"Can Fishy die?" The game has no fail states, and this scene is not an exception. The condition is a plot device that pushes Harold to the pharmacy.
"I reloaded to pick the other one." Reloading costs you more than it gives you. One save slot means a reload drops you at the last autosave, which can wipe a day of optional conversations. The choice is not worth a reload.
"Does it affect the ending?" No. Harold's decision in the last chapter is scripted and does not read on the medicine, the dinner, or how many side tasks you finished.
Where this page fits
The medicine day is one of six sub-chapters in chapter 2, and the chapter 2 walkthrough covers the rest, including the curfew and the Lightkeepers message. Collectors get nothing from the medicine itself, though the surrounding conversations are entries: the notebook page lists which ones sit in this chapter.
The rarest achievement does not care about the medicine at all, and the 100% route says so in one line. Most of what makes Forschergeist hard is in chapters 1, 2 and 4, in exactly the kind of one-day window this chapter teaches you to respect.